When you hear the word "vaccine," do you immediately think of the word "autism?" If so, you're not alone. The purported link between vaccinations and autism has been big news in recent years. Stars like Jenny McCarthy have claimed in the media that vaccines caused her child's disorder, while celebrities such as Amanda Peet have spoken about the importance of vaccinating children. So, with all the conflicting information, whom do you believe?

 

 

According to the CDC, there is no link between autism and vaccines.  In fact, it was recently proven that the doctor who first made the connection faked his results.  Yet, some mothers whose children showed symptoms of autism shortly after vaccination remain convinced that the vaccine caused the disorder.  Heather Armstrong of Dooce asks our panelists, "Are you concerned about vaccinations?

 

 

 

What are your thoughts regarding vaccinations and autism?  Did you vaccinate your child?  Why or why not?  Join the Momversation by taking our vaccination poll and commenting.


More videos on Health & Fitness ... Browse all 29 videos

Showing the Latest of 136 Comments

Daddy Scratches
1 years ago
One lesson about parenting that I learned during my wife's pregnancy is that, like it or not, you have to play the odds. At one point, we were advised that we could have an amniocentesis conducted to check for a certain chromosomal disorder ... but, based on the figures provided to us, the odds of the amnio causing some kind of problem were greater than the odds of our unborn child being afflicted with the chromosomal disorder in question. Thus, we passed on getting the amnio. With regard to vaccination: we felt that the odds of our children developing a life-threatening illness if not vaccinated posed a greater risk than the odds of our children developing autism in the wake of their vaccinations. Thus, we got them vaccinated. Now, if they *had* developed symptoms of autism, I'm sure I'd be singing a much different tune, and therefore I have no quarrel with parents who, after being put in that unfortunate position, advocate not getting your child vaccinated. Short of any irrefutable evidence that vaccinations cause autism, however, I agree that the ability to vaccinate your child against illnesses that once killed people in large numbers is a medical advance worth taking advantage of. (FWIW: My wife has a master's degree in social work and works as the clinical coordinator for a program that provides services to adolescents on the autism spectrum, so she is perhaps more tuned in than most people to the issues surrounding that community ... and she had no hesitation about getting our kids vaccinated.)
 
islandmama4ever
1 years ago
I completely respect the value of vaccination and its importance in keeping at bay the horrific diseases that we have made such progress in getting control over. However, I choose to modify the approach and not use the aggressive traditional approach. I am consciously researching the manufacturers of the various vaccines and weighing their contents and processes. As a result, my as-yet-unborn child will be vaccinated, but on a modified and more spread out schedule so that my husband and I have a greater involvement in how much our child is being exposed to at any given time.
 
queen-of-paci
1 years ago
I agree! Have you read the book by Dr. Sears? I think every one should read it before vaccinating. Mercury is not the enemy anymore it is Aluminum. If you follow the CDC guidlines you are given your prefect newborn baby a TOXIC level of Aluminum. Please go to Dr. Sears web site. This book is so easy to read.
 
BabyDust
1 years ago
I agree that there is no evidence currently that vaccinations cause autsim. I also wouldn't vaccinate my child for any reason. Autism seems to always been seen as the reason parents don't vaccinate and I can tell you that, for me, it couldn't be farther from the truth. The multitude of other reactions (Guillain-Barré, SIDS, Juvenile Diabetes, Rheumatoid Arthritis, anaphylactic shock, death, etc.) had a much larger impact on me. Also, I'm not inherently distrustful of the medical industry (I conceived through IVF so I LOVE modern medicine!) but when they are pushing a HepB vaccine on a 12 hour old infant their motives become suspect. It is frustrating to me that the vaccine debate swirls around Autism, MMR, and Jenny McCarthy. It is like this is a *new* problem! Have we forgotten Barbara Loe Fisher and her fight to get DTP off the market? It was killing kids and causing developmental disabilities in others and they've since changed it (to DTaP, the "a" being acelular). For some reason the media loves the Autism link - perhaps because it is so pervasive and not understood disorder? Regardless, it is the least of the problems with vaccines - so please research beyond Autism when you are exploring vaccines. I also wanted to point out a major flaw in the panelists discussion of non-vaxers. There is this persistent idea that vaccinating is a societal obligation and moral imperative. This theory stems from the thought that non-vaccinated children are relying on the "herd" to protect them from illness. Also, since some people can't get vaccines for medical reasons that non-vaccinated children are posing a threat to them. There are several major flaws with this idea. the largest of which is children are only a minority of the human "herd" - what about the adult population that harbor NO IMMUNITY to illnesses because they have waned from vaccines and were never developed naturally through illness. Even the CDC shows grave numbers for adult vaccination. http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/14/vaccinations-for-grown-ups/ "only 2.1 percent of adults ages 18 to 64 are immunized against tetanus, diphtheria and whooping cough, the journal reports. A vaccine against shingles is recommended for all adults over 60, but only 1.9 percent of adults have been immunized." How can the non-vaccinated children be responsible for the lack of eradication of these vaccine available diseases? If herd immunity requires 70-90% immunity levels, how can we pretend to have herd immunity? Second, if you believe that vaccine's work, why are you worried about your vaccinated child? This doesn't apply to those too young to be vaccinated and those who can not - however I've heard parents of vaccinated kids blame the non-vaccinated kids. Why aren't they upset at the medical community because their vaccine didn't work? Lastly, read up on what vaccines actually do. Many don't prevent transmission of an disease but decrease the severity of the illness. Whooping Cough, for example, does not stop transmission. That means your vaccinated child can have the pathogen and pass it to others but may not have any symptoms or very light symptoms. If a baby or immuno-compromised person gets Pertussis how do we know it is a non-vaccinated person's fault? Once again, why aren't we railing at the medical community that these vaccines aren't living up to their *miracle status*? I respect anyone's decision to vaccinate or not vaccinate. Trust me, thinking that my child would be the one that got HepB from some freak accident and died kept me up late at night! It isn't an easy decision but let's protect everyone's right to make an informed decision.
 
LauraThompson
1 years ago
I really hate to bottom-line a subject as complex as this, but here it is: I'd rather my child be autistic than dead. Until irrefutable evidence is given that vaccinations are more dangerous than not getting vaccinations, I will continue to support them. As Daddy Scratches pointed out above, the odds indicate that vaccinations are safer than no vaccines.
 
robinj
1 years ago
Really? You would rather have a child with autism than a child with chicken pox? Do you know even one child who died of chicken pox? Mumps? Measels? My prematurely born son was vaccinated for HEP B on the second day of his life when he still should have been a fetus. That's what the medical professionals in the hospital did because it was their "policy". I have yet to meet a premature baby (or full term baby for that matter) that was an IV drug user, traveled to third world countries or had unprotected sex. (and BTW, I was tested for Hep B and was neg, this info was part of my chart while in the hospital delivering my premature baby) This is really so insulting to those of us who live and struggle with autism every day.
 
Talon
1 years ago
I have a child with a spectrum disorder. I also have a dead child. If a shot could have saved his life, you bet your ass I would have given it to him. As it was, he died of HLHS. And yes, I know plenty of children or at least OF plenty of children who have died of chicken pox, measles, mumps, whooping cough. I have a compromised immune system. I rely on herd immunity to keep me alive and healthy. So do many MANY imuno compromised children. And since we delayed my daughter's vaccinations BECAUSE at the time the evidence was still up in the air, and the evidence of spectrum disorders is HUGE in our family, I can say that her disorder was not caused by her vaccinations, but more than likely her genetics. So, you're not the only parent who struggles with autism every day. Do I think your preemie needed the HEP B shot while he was in the nicu? No. Do I think you're overreacting and downplaying the very real concerns of parents who don't want dead children. I do. Being a bereaved parent is no fun. Being the parent of any kind of special needs child is a challenge. But I'll take the challenge any day over the grief of my boy who would have been twelve this May.
 
AZ Writer
1 years ago
Wow. I missed this last time I read through the comments. I really don't have any more to add, but I wanted to thank you for your input and offer whatever sympathies and thoughts I can to you and your family. Thanks for your point of view; it gives us all (me, at least, and I assume on the behalf of others) a lot to consider. I'm hugging my son extra, extra tight right now.
 
momma81
1 years ago
I am so sorry for the loss of your son. My reason for vaccinating is also because of the very real benefits of herd immunity. When I was pregnant, I found out that my lack of measles immunity posed a scary risk to my unborn child. One chance encounter with rubella could have killed my baby's chance of a future. Period. I agree with Asha in that public health has made huge strides in the health of our society, and we should take advantage, and be thankful for, the benefits of vaccinations. As an RN, I have seen babies with pertussis, and it is not a pretty sight. I am thankful that we don't usually have to face the scary reality of disease outbreaks that are not uncommon in third world countries. I truly believe that those who choose not to vaccinate their children are imposing health risks on other people and other people's children. That said, I think giving a Hep B immunization to a small baby is pretty ridiculous, so we should all vaccinate with discretion.
 
Natural Mother
1 years ago
Children with compromised immune systems/autoimmune diseases are at the highest risk to have an adverse reaction to live virus vaccines while all vaccines given too early to immune suppressed infants can hinder the natural development of their already compromised systems. While not all children who have spectrum disorders are caused by vaccinations, we have to ask ourselves why exactly it is there are so many more children with those disorders now than 20 years ago. And please don't say that there were but they just weren't diagnosed properly because if that were true, we would have many more adults being diagnosed now. But again, the fears for many regarding immunizations aren't just about Autism. There is a blood test that can be done to determine whether or not an infant has a suppressed immune system before she/he is given vaccinations but unfortunately, it is rarely given and unless requested by the primary doctor, is rarely covered by insurance.
 

Post new comment

Want to leave a video comment? Drop
a link to your youtube video here!