Sign In
or Join Momversation

 

Embed this Video

Comment (38)

February 09, 2009

FB Share

Salmonella in the peanut butter.  Mercury in high fructose corn syrup.  Lead in children's toys.  It seems that everywhere we turn, there are toxins galore.  But are the risks from these blown out of proportion?  Alice Bradley from Finslippy asks, "Is the toxin danger real or just hype?"
 
How do you handle all of the scares about toxins?  Do you continually purify your environment?  Do you just ignore them?  And who did poop in those peanuts, anyway?  Join the Momversation by commenting in one of our related forums:

Panelists
 
Keywords
 
 
 

 

38 Comments

 
Apmfyczu

Ewgwergjhvw

Thu, 2010-03-04 11:03

 
Jqbhyczq

Ewgwergjhvw

Wed, 2010-03-03 18:32

 

test

Tue, 2009-05-12 01:58

 

I'm with PearlBerries, there's not a Whole Foods/Trader Joe's/any of those other popular healthy places within a 30 minute drive of my house. So I do the best I can with what I have available. I live in such a "red" county, the grocery cashiers are still slightly shocked if you buy all-natural peanut butter because that's something only done by them thar Communists and Hippies! (besides which I think all natural PB tastes like potting soil). So, our chocolate syrup is just going to have to have HFCS in it. But then I make extra effort to properly wash fruits and veggies, buying maybe not the healthiest bread but certainly healthier than what I grew up eating. Its all a balance.

Mon, 2009-03-02 12:37

 

My toddler is allergic to more than half the food a normal American eats. At 6 mo. following the books, of course, we discovered rather quickly that life was going to be seriously different for us. We -have- to watch what we eat, where we eat. And you know what? It's been an improvement for all of us.

As for lead, geez. We toss toys we see on the news and limit painted toys. We're trying for mostly wood or hand made, but even that holds no guarantee.

It's a scary time to be a parent now, I think. My grandparents just let kids play anywhere outside. My parents kept us within the fence, wary of strangers. And here we are afraid of the shit inside the house. Absolute mess!

Highlight?
Bagged salads... "that shit's convenient"-Alice
Damn straight, girl.

Sun, 2009-02-22 18:43

 

I don't know if anyone's still following this thread or if anyone else read -- and laughed at -- the New York Times op-ed piece on Friday called "The Maggots in Your Mushrooms." But it made me think a bit more about the differences between the risks of processed foods and natural foods, and about how not to feel overwhelmed and scared by the prospect of salmonella in our peanutbutter.

http://www.yogamamame.com/2009/02/id-rather-have-my-mushrooms-fresh-with...

Mon, 2009-02-16 11:37

 

I do the best I can, but I am also studying to be a naturopathic physician, which gives me an edge in that I have had countless hours of doctorate level training in toxic exposures, where they can come from, and what they may or may not do to your body. I do not purport to be an expert, or give any medical adivice, but this is what I do for my family. I do not use anti bacterial soap because regular soap, water, and scrubbing generally suffice, however, when I am in clinic, exposed to many sick people, I will gladly use antimicrobial soaps, and even that sticky hand sanitizer. Depends on the situation. I try to wash most of my veggies, especially the leafy or creviced ones, unless they are the ones from my own garden, because food born ilness sucks and can be a real danger. Lead in childrens toys, unfortunate since babies put everything into their mouths, it's part of their development and teaches them spatial relations as well as which toy has that just perfect flavor. My favorite as a child was barbie feet. I now buy mostly organic cotton toys, or natural wood toys that go the extra mile to prove to me their safety. I also do a lot of books, sewing kits, and other things that are not technically "toys". High fructose corn syrup is not my friend. it's everywhere and has been linked to too many health problems that my family is prone to for me to knowingly let it come into my home. The mercury content may be miniscule, but miniscule added up, many times over throughtout the day or the week may be more than my body, or my childrens' bodies can adequately handle, so we avoid it. I am not perfect, and I do know that we are exposed to these and many other avoidable toxins daily, so I do the best I can, cross my fingers and toes, and eat my greens. Or maybe it was an apple.

Thu, 2009-02-12 15:10

 

The toxins! My husband and I were just talking about this last night, because he got tired of me yapping about the parabens in my favorite hand cream.

I'm very focused on food additives and industrial chemicals mainly because (and here's where I disagree with Giyen) companies are generally not forthcoming about testing or risks and U.S. agencies don't have chompy regulatory teeth. When you see a recall, it's because an actuarial table or insurance company or law firm advised that the risks were so substantial as to warrant the costs of a recall. Which is why BPA is still a-ok here in the U.S. and our beauty products are loaded with crap you couldn't even consider selling in the EU.

I'm also focused on these issues because I believe in the theory that your genetic code is a loaded gun and your environment can pull the trigger.

So, like Mindy, what I can control, I do. Where I draw the line is over-sanitization and my personal use of antibiotics. I'm about to have my first baby and I refuse to turn into a Purell-squirting, bleach-dunking, Zithromax-pounding mom.

Thu, 2009-02-12 07:32

 

There's no need to freak out about all the news reports. But any mom or dad worth their salt should educate themselves about the good staff and bad stuff our kids come in contact with inside and outside of the house.

Thank goodness it's easier to be green than ever before.

Tracy
http://themoxiereport.blogspot.com

Wed, 2009-02-11 17:17

 
Pat

I usually don't worry about this kind of stuff.. It's only when I moved to Canada that I saw that pesticides and polycar.. whatervers where an issue.. maybe because in Haiti (that is where I grew up) we eat more from the source.. so if you want chicken.. you need to go out there and kill it.. just kidding! but that is basically it.

Wed, 2009-02-11 07:33

 

I had to post again because I've seen so many comments on other sites about how the latest recall is just hype.

Giyen--I'm glad you said something. I got sick (see above salmonella post) from a restaurant, and while I'm sure they did what they could to maintain a clean kitchen, sh** happens (literally in this case, I guess!). In fact, a few months later there was local news about restaurants getting fish from China that tested positive for a bunch of stuff, salmonella included.

Food-borne illness shouldn't really have a place in a discussion about over-worry and scare tactics, because it does pose a real threat. When there's a threat that can be isolated, then those in the position to do so should take care of it. And that's what they did. I don't see the issue. Personally, when I hear about these recalls, I think to myself, "whew, one less way for me to get sick again". Maybe everyone needs to suffer a major bacterial infection once in their life to understand the severity?

Tue, 2009-02-10 19:31

 

test

Tue, 2009-05-12 01:58

 

test

Tue, 2009-05-12 01:39

 

giyen, i'm with you on that one... as the mom to a 9 month old who has already been diagnosed with cyclic vomiting syndrome, i am forced to watch every little thing that goes in my son's mouth because if he consumes something that is new or that his body doesn't agree with, i will shortly be wearing it.

even still, i can't tell you how much i really don't like that i have to do that. (i know that sounds bad and selfish, but hear me out.) i feel like there are soooooooo many battles that we, as moms, have to endure when it comes to our kids. food is one that i just wish were not one of those battles, and with jackson having his feeding issues already, i have to fight it. so i guess it is what it is... i just wish it weren't.

i have a friend who emailed me weeks ago about a pacifier issue she had. she saw that jackson had a pacifier from a picture on my blog. she then proceeded to tell me why my 9 month old should not have a pacifier, then she told me about her son's old pacifier (that he now does not use it because she won't allow it) and said that she looked it up on a website where she found that it contained arsenic.

it should be noted that i never responded to this email of her's, simply because i don't respond to unsolicited advice (unless it's from my mom). pro-pacifier or anti... whatever works for you. i just don't like homies checking out pics of my kid and then emailing me saying, "jackson really shouldn't have that. he's a little old for a pacifier."

i did however check out the website she sent me and her pacifier theory... what i found was that the pacifier reportedly had 4 parts per million of arsenic. and apparently in the u.s.a. 25 parts per million of arsenic are allowed without it causing harm or issue.

a little nutsy in my mind... i am amazed that she did the research she did. i hardly have the time to update my blog. :)

Tue, 2009-02-10 18:21

 

Here's the thing. I worked in the restaurant industry for 10 years. The last place I was employed (back in the 90s) received a 100% rating (no deficiencies) and that place had marginal sanitary practices, in my opinion. Eggs left out on the counter, sushi not properly refrigerated, things left out "accidentally" over night. You name it. No one that I knew of got sick. People kept coming in to eat in droves and there were never any issues regarding the food.

The thing that makes me the most fearful is the human component when it comes to processing food and other products. And of course, unenforced governmental regulations. I think that's why I stick to eating as locally as possible.

We can't be perfect and we all have to do what we can ... but I can't agree with @maybebaby more:

"you can only do so much and that every little change you make is better than making no change at all."

Tue, 2009-02-10 13:58

 

I'm more with Alice on this one. I can't be flippant about these issues.

I agree that there's a huge hype component that makes people uber fearful of "hidden dangers" and that in turn makes them feel out of control. I too think there's something really wrong with the fact that Salmonella is cropping up in Peanut Butter and produce, and that Melamine is finding it's way into Formula and Pet Food. I mean, who on Earth (who isn't allergic!) doesn't eat or give their kids or pets Peanut Butter at some point in their lives?? I don't really consider that a "processed food" like I do "processed cheese food" (WTF?!). On the rare occasion that I do buy Peanut Butter, I try to buy organic so that it's not full of nasty chemicals and devoid of nutrition, however Salmonella is just as likely to be in those peanuts as in any other type of Peanut Butter. The fact is, although it's totally shit for stuff like this to be happening in the first place, we can't necessarily see it coming and therefore can't control it.

What drives me crazy is that the things we CAN control are usually the things we SHOULD be worried about and generally aren't. Lets look at Flame Retardants all over our furniture and kids sleep clothes! Lets look at endocrine disruptor in our cosmetics and soap! So many companies couldn't give a shit about the problems the chemicals in their products could cause. God I hate to be the "studies show" person, but its true that studies have shown our pets are being diagnosed more and more with cancer. Think about it - they live and breathe and eat close to the ground, licking and sleeping on floors that are covered in the dust coming off our our flame retardant doused electronics equipment and furniture. Now think about putting your sensitive new baby on that floor. Think about that phone your toddler just stuck in his mouth.

Hey, I'm all for germs! Germs can be good sometimes. But my generation (I'm 27) and the generations that follow me are increasingly exposed to an onslaught of chemicals in our environment. If I suffer from infertility some day, is that because I've been washing my hands and hair with soaps full of endocrine disruptors since I was born? What early tragedies are we potentially setting our babies of today up with for tomorrow because we turned a blind eye to the crap that manufactures are sticking in the stuff we live with and use and eat on a daily basis?

The idea that Christmas Lights have lead in the plastic wiring makes me sick, but there's nothing I can do about that OTHER THAN ADVOCATE FOR CHANGE. Until then I just have to live with it. I pick my battles. As best I can, I don't use polycarbonate plastics to avoid BPA exposure and I never ever microwave anything in any kind of plastic. I use heavy cleaners to do tough jobs rather than every job. I dust, a lot. When I buy furniture, I buy from companies (IKEA for example) that don't use formaldehyde in their pressed wood, and when I pick new sofas someday I'll buy from companies that are committed to using as many natural, untreated products as they can.

I sleep pretty good at night knowing that I'm being active on the things I can control and trying not to freak out on things that I cant. My prime example is that government regulation stipulates when flame retardants are used and what can be used. I do not agree with those regulations so I use my voice to raise awareness about it until I have a choice between sofas and TVs with flame retardants and those without. And when I need new things, I find companies who voluntarily pledge not to use chemicals in their products that have been proven to be of serious health risk but have not yet been banned by the US Government.

I do what I can but I'm not unreasonable. For instance, I live in Texas and despite all the advice not to use pesticides, I just don't have the choice unless I want to find cockroaches in my toilet paper rolls and in my sofa. Id rather mitigate my risk by eliminating or limiting things I can control so that the things I cant (or can't do without) don't snow ball the issue.

I think that's the most important thing we have to consider - pick your battles and mitigate risk where possible.

Its just that so few people realize the extent of the control that manufacturing and mass food production have on our lives. The least we can do is be informed. Then at least we can decide what battles to pick. If we don't read and educate ourselves, our battles are picked for us and our kids will eventually be the ones who loose.

Pick your battles. Educate Yourself:

http://www.ewg.org/
http://healthychild.org/
http://www.thegreenguide.com/
http://www.grist.org/
http://www.enviroblog.org/

Most importantly, realize that you can only do so much and that every little change you make is better than making no change at all.

Tue, 2009-02-10 11:49

 
acm

Put me in the category that wishes we had more mothers of young infants in the group. While I'm generally in the category of not worrying about sudden outbreaks of nasty bacteria, and generally just practicing common-sense hygiene, *chemicals* are quite scary and something that I feel (a) wasn't really an issue when we were kids (when some of these plastics didn't even exist) and (b) could really affect our young kids.

I've got a one-year old, and I was careful to get bottles that didn't have bisphenol-A, but now it turns out that a large number of teether and other plastic toys have that same kind of plastic (which leaches endocrine disrupters), as do many types of babyfood packaging! (See, e.g., http://thesoftlanding.wordpress.com/ ) It can be so hard to find developmentally appropriate and satisfying toys (and foods the kid will eat, etc.) already, that somehow having to cross-reference any prospect against a dozen websites tracking their chemical compositions seems too disheartening to face, but it looks like some of these substances are about to be banned. Am torn between doing the intense research (and possibly throwing out half the stuff in the house) and just avoiding the whole thing (and thus hoping my daughter will just Be Strong or something). help!!!

Tue, 2009-02-10 11:26

 

My son's two, and my second is due in less than a month, so I hear you -- and also have the perspective of someone who wouldn't even let the dogs near her first child for a few month and now envisions putting the new infant in its moses basket right on the floor with the hounds. The thing about harmful products like BPA is that don't know about all of them -- and they occur in very small amounts. We were very, very careful to avoid toxins & didn't find out about BPA until my son was almost a year old and moving away from the Advent bottles we used ... that turned out to be some of the worst BPA offenders. At that point, I just couldn't regret -- only appreciate that I was doing my best.

Just wanted to add -- for anyone who wants another headache -- that a big source of BPA that has received little attention is can liners. Almost all canned foods (with the exception of Eden Organics, as far as I know) have liners made of BPA. Much of this food is also cooked inside the can, triggering exactly the properties of BPA we are trying to avoid. I've learned how to cook dried beans but I do miss the canned refried beans my son used to enjoy. I guess I'll have to learn how to make big batches of them as well.

Tue, 2009-02-10 20:37

 

I agree with Mindy's approach to common sense. Yes, we try very, VERY hard to get whole foods (I triple dog dare you to find a whole foods store by me. Go ahead, TRY) but in the end, I make the best choices with what I have available. And I wash everything I can. And I am an absolute fruit loop about food being unsafe/spoiled/in the fridge too long. And I don't like raw meat juices touching anything. Then the (natural) disinfectant spray comes out and I have been known to go a little overboard with my cleaning. *ahem*

In the end, I believe I have made the best choices I can and don't freak out about it. My mental capacity is better spent on healthy endevors, not irrational freak outs (excluding the meat thing, because that is not irrational. Right??).

Tue, 2009-02-10 09:19

 

Once my daughter developed Type 1 diabetes when she was three (no, I don't think it was from any of these things listed), I realized that a real and irrational fear is. I must fear for her daily on just eating in general and what normal food could do to her, let alone chemicals, preservatives etc.

When you get a wake up call such as that, it puts things into perspective big time on picking your battles, ie worries.

Mon, 2009-02-09 22:49

 

I refuse to live in fear of all these toxins and microbes and bacteria and viruses that are all around me and my family. I mean, I will be smart about cleaning my cutting board and washing my veggies but I am not going to take every toy to the laboratory and have it tested for mercury and lead. I'd rather spend the money and time on quality time with the kids.

=)

So much of American consumerism is driven by fear. That's how all the antibacterial stuffs got sold. If we used the money we spent on antibacterial stuffs and invested it on getting clean water to children who live in poverty, I think we would have saved a lot more lives.

Mon, 2009-02-09 22:02

 

Oh, yeah -- bacteria and dirt? Not a concern. It's the deliberate stuff -- the processing of foods and over-vaccination of children that gets me. If it's engineered to somehow improve our health, I'm skeptical. If it's all natural dirt (to be found just below all the places I let the dogs clean up after Jack's meals), I'm with you.

And, yes, it is amazing how much money is spent getting us to spend money on useless items like antibacterial stuffs instead of real health concerns (that will not generate any profits).

Tue, 2009-02-10 20:32

 

Thanks my Kimchi sister. I feel better now.

I don't think our grandmothers were really worried about bacteria when they were burying those pots of kimchi in the backyard. Lol.

Tue, 2009-02-10 14:03

 

Funny (or, perhaps, not), but I just wrote a long piece about this very topic -- how I am supposed to feed my son now that I just finished reading Michael Pollan's In Defense of Food. (http://YogaMamaMe.com) And I wasn't even looking at the salmonella scare because I'm lucky enough to have a husband with a peanut allergy and a son who very likely may have inherited it. So I get to think, as do the panelists, "Ha! I don't give my family peanutbutter or processed foods that might, for some reason we can not explain, have peanutbutter in them."

As to the whole debate about whether we are going overboard (and Peggy Orenstein wrote an interesting essay about just this question in yesterday's New York Times Magazine), what I concluded after batting it around was that we all have to make the choice we feel is the right one. I do feel, very strongly, that most of the food in supermarkets isn't really food; that the dangers of off-gassing are way under-noticed; and that I will -- perhaps literally -- die the first time my child demands a Happy Meal.

I do my best to create as toxic-free an environment as possible for my son (and myself, since I'm 8 months pregnant) precisely because I know there are a million other toxins out there that I can do nothing about. It's about doing your best, making your choices as a mom and as a human being, and then giving yourself a break. Not having to explain yourself. Knowing you did your best.

That said, dear god, what will I do if they find out something is wrong with Annie's Mac & Cheese? Jack will starve right along with Henry.

Mon, 2009-02-09 13:53

 

The more I think about scary things, the more scared I get. I try to avoid that cycle. I used to be affraid of spiders, then I lived in an old trailer home for a year, that pretty much cured it. Now I don't even try to squish them. I get spooked about sharks in the deep end of the swimming pool even though I know they aren't there. I handle it by diving in. After the invisible sharks don't eat me, I start to feel a lot better.
I don't want to get sick, so I wash stuff (I spray all fruits and veggies with white vinegar and let em be for a couple minutes before rinsing well) and I try to avoid foods that are unnecessarily processed for me. Other than that, I don't even think about it. I'll freak out if I do. Sience has been telling me that freaking out is unhealthy too. In the end, it's probably what really ends up killing most of us. Kinda funny in a dark, morbid sort of way.
Deep breath. Sigh. I'm ok, I'm ok, I'm ok.

Mon, 2009-02-09 11:45

 

Mindy... your friend's pediatrician should have told her that a child under the age on one should NEVER be given honey... for just the reason you speak of. So sorry she had to learn the hard way. Spread the word about this to everyone with infants.

Mon, 2009-02-09 11:14

 

I usually don't worry about the news. Perhaps it's because I was born and raised in Italy where we are too nonchalant about this kind of stuff. But I have to say that one of my children had Salmonella and was so ill for weeks, it made me much more aware of being careful about these things. Not obsessive but careful.
Salmonella is really rough for little kids - better safe than sorry :)
Cheers,
Anita
www.ovolina.com

Mon, 2009-02-09 10:40

 

Sorry ladies, my salmonella rant was a little crazy and not really helpful for the discussion, it was pre-tea. Hugs all around, great video as usual, try not to get sick from your peanut butter :)

Mon, 2009-02-09 10:21

 

test

Tue, 2009-05-12 01:10

 

Actually, I have to give you props! My brother had Salmonella and it was awfulllll. Granted, he did eat a chicken sandwich that had been left out overnight, but still. Didn't make it any less dangerous.

And here's something no one seems to worry about: botulism. A friend gave her daughter botulism at six months from... are you ready? Honey. She was paralyzed, and had to learn to sit up and crawl all over again. Honey is touted as the one food that does not spoil, but it's friendly to other things we're better off not contracting. That doesn't mean I don't eat it, I just—as monsterwrangler said—say Grace first.

Mon, 2009-02-09 10:26

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. Next
 
 

Best of Momversation

 
 

Did You Take Your Husband's Name?

Some women still get disapproving looks when they state that they didn't take their husband's last name. …

151 Comments

 
 

Childfree by Choice

There's a growing movement across the blogosphere of people who have chosen to remain childless. …

210 Comments

 
 

Is Circumcision Wrong?

It's a tough decision that every American mother of a baby boy has to make: to circumcise or not…

344 Comments

 
 

Are You Concerned About Vaccinations?

When you hear the word "vaccine," do you immediately think of the word "autism?" …

128 Comments

 
 

Favorite Quotes

 
 

On behalf of the parents of autistic children I know, Jenny McCarthy can go &*$% herself.

Doctors or Parents: Who Do You Trust More?

 
 

I can't plan anything a year in advance. I certainly can't plan 365 meals, nor would I ever want to.

Meal Planning for a Year: Crazy Talk?

 
 

We've been conditioned to think that only one way is acceptable.

Life Experiences: Do They Count as Education?

 
 

My husband is not Mr. Romantic, but that's OK because he can fix the tires on a stroller.

Valentine's Day: Is It Important to You?

 
 

Sometimes it works out great, and sometimes she wants the $195 flat iron.

Thankful: How Do You Teach Your Kids to Be Grateful?

 
 

Heather, it's going to be your duty to teach our daughter about her cheeseburger.

Private Parts: Do You Have Cutesy Names for Them?

 
 

When you have something wrong with your child's health, a lot of parents need to cling to something.

Vaccines and Autism: Debate Over?

 
 

The reality is if you have kids at your house often enough, the accidents will happen.

Accidents Happen: When Someone Else's Kid Gets Hurt on Your Watch

 
 

My husband is the gadgety person. My God, that man has gadgets. And they never work. What is that?

Gotta-Have Gadget: What's Yours?

 
 

Your 6 week old is not interested in anything but light and shadow.

Milestones: What's the Rush?

 
 

Americans eat too much. Eat half!

Best Weight Loss Tips Ever

 
 

What I really want to accomplish is raising children who are advocates for themselves.

Advocating for Your Child

 
 

Categories

 

Celebrity

99
 

Contest

10
 

Education

40
 

Family

129
 

Food

92
 

Friends and Relationships

74
 

Fun and Leisure

66
 

Health

114
 

Home and Garden

21
 

Hot Topics

66
 

Link Roundup

186
 

Lists

67
 

Mom Daily

160
 

Mommy Talk

253
 

Moms 'Round the Web

23
 

Momversation News

41
 

Momversation Panelists

55
 

News and Politics

53
 

Parenting

222
 

Poll

31
 

Pregnancy

115
 

Sex

23
 

Shopping

47
 

Style and Fashion

24
 

Technology

46
 

Tips and Resources

68
 

Video

179
 

Work and Money

51
 

Subscribe

Stay up-to-date on the Momversation by subscribing to our RSS feeds and joining our weekly newsletter.

Comments
Video
Subscribe in iTunes

Newsletter

Stay informed on our latest news!